In a seismic shift of long-standing policy, the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has agreed to share specific taxpayer data with immigration authorities—a move poised to dramatically alter the landscape for immigrants seeking to secure or adjust their legal status. Experts warn that the ripple effects could be far broader, with the U.S. Treasury facing a staggering financial blow.
According to a detailed report released yesterday by the Yale Budget Lab, a non-partisan policy research center, the IRS stands to lose over $313 billion in tax revenue over the next decade as a direct consequence of the decision. The reason: fear.
Undocumented workers, who historically contribute significant sums to the federal treasury, may now avoid filing taxes altogether or underreport income, worried their information could be weaponized against them by immigration enforcement.
A Dangerous Trade-Off
The Yale Budget Lab’s analysis forecasts a $12 billion drop in tax revenues for the current fiscal year ending September 30 alone. In fiscal year 2023, undocumented workers paid an estimated $66 billion in federal taxes—two-thirds of it through payroll contributions like Social Security and Medicare, despite many being ineligible to receive the associated benefits.
“This is a dangerous trade-off,” said Dr. Lillian Moore, lead researcher at Yale Budget Lab. “You are sacrificing hundreds of billions in lawful tax collections in exchange for minor gains in immigration enforcement. It’s fiscally reckless.”
The agreement, quietly inked between the Treasury Department, which oversees the IRS, and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), permits immigration officials to request access to taxpayer information specifically for law enforcement purposes. While the Biden administration asserts that the arrangement is limited to criminal cases, critics argue that the erosion of decades-old privacy protections could create a chilling effect far beyond criminal matters.
New Challenges for Immigrants
For immigrants navigating America’s notoriously complex immigration system, the consequences could be profound.
“The IRS’s decision to share tax data with immigration agencies means immigrants’ tax records could now directly impact visa, green card, or citizenship applications,” explained Aditya Bhattacharya, a partner at King Stubb & Kasiva, Advocates and Attorneys. “Filing taxes accurately—even via an ITIN [Individual Taxpayer Identification Number] for undocumented individuals—is critical. Discrepancies, non-filing, or inconsistencies could cause significant delays or even lead to denials, while clean records could be used as evidence of financial responsibility and good moral character.”
Many immigration applications rely on showing continuous employment, financial stability, and adherence to U.S. laws—all of which could now be directly verified against IRS records.
Eroding Trust in the System
For decades, the IRS had been viewed by tax filers—immigrants and citizens alike—as an agency separated from immigration enforcement. This trust was essential in encouraging voluntary compliance. By voluntarily filing taxes, millions of undocumented immigrants not only contributed to public services but also laid important groundwork for future legal status adjustments.
That trust, experts say, is now in peril.
“This is a gut punch to the entire tax system,” warned Michael Estrada, a former IRS attorney. “When you destroy confidentiality, you destroy compliance. People won’t come forward voluntarily anymore, and once that culture of fear takes root, it’s incredibly hard to undo.”
Political Firestorm Ahead
The decision has already triggered a political firestorm. Immigrant advocacy groups, privacy watchdogs, and even some fiscal conservatives are expressing alarm at the potential fallout.
“This policy is short-sighted and self-defeating,” said Marisol Peña, Director of the Immigrant Legal Resource Center. “It doesn’t just punish immigrants. It punishes every American who depends on a functioning tax system and adequately funded public services.”
Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle are now signaling plans to introduce legislation to either reinforce IRS privacy protections or more narrowly define the circumstances under which tax data can be shared.
A Precarious Path Forward
For now, immigrants are being urged by legal experts to continue filing taxes but to be more cautious than ever. Proper documentation, accuracy, and legal advice are becoming not just important but essential.
“We are in new territory,” said Bhattacharya. “Immigrants must treat tax compliance as a critical part of their immigration strategy moving forward.”
Also Read : Tabitha Nauser: Singing Her Way Into Hearts Around the Globe