Indian Immigrants Cut US Debt by $1.6M Each, Study Finds

In a twist of economic irony, former U.S. President Donald Trump and his MAGA base may be vilifying Indian and Indian-origin professionals, but new research shows that these very immigrants are among the most valuable to America’s economy. Despite facing online hostility and immigration challenges, Indian immigrants reduce US national debt more than any other group, according to a groundbreaking study by economist Daniel Di Martino of the Manhattan Institute.

As anti-Indian sentiment flared across social media following Diwali celebrations and a recent California crash involving an Indian driver, Di Martino’s findings emerged as a powerful counter-narrative — one rooted in data, not prejudice.

“Crazy people on X are bashing Indian immigrants, but my new research published today finds that Indians are the best major country of origin group of immigrants,” he posted on X (formerly Twitter). His study shows that the average Indian immigrant and their descendants save the U.S. federal government $1.7 million over 30 years, making them America’s most fiscally beneficial immigrant group.

Indian Immigrants: The Economic Backbone of the American Dream

The research comprehensively measures the fiscal, GDP, and population impact of immigrants by origin, legal status, and education. Di Martino’s analysis concludes that South Asians—particularly Indians—have the most positive economic impact on the U.S. economy, followed by Western Europeans and East Asians. Only Central American and Mexican immigrants show a net negative fiscal impact.

“Among large immigrant groups, Indian immigrants stand out as the most economically beneficial,” the study emphasizes. On average, Indian immigrants reduce the national debt by $1.6 million over three decades while contributing more to GDP growth than immigrants from any other country.

Trailing behind them are Chinese immigrants, who reduce the debt by around $800,000, followed by Filipinos ($600,000), Colombians ($500,000), and Venezuelans ($400,000). At the opposite end of the spectrum, Salvadorans increase the debt by over $50,000, while Mexicans—America’s largest immigrant group—raise it by about $10,000 each over the same period.

H-1B Visa Holders: America’s Unsung Economic Heroes

Di Martino’s research also sheds light on the economic power of H-1B visa holders, the majority of whom are Indian professionals in technology, healthcare, and finance. These high-skilled workers, often criticized under Trump’s restrictive immigration policies, contribute immensely to America’s fiscal health.

“The much-discussed H-1B visa is the best single visa type in terms of economic impact,” Di Martino notes. “The average H-1B holder reduces the national debt by $2.3 million over 30 years and expands GDP by $500,000.”

Despite Trump’s past attempts to tighten H-1B rules, the data suggests that these skilled Indian professionals are key to strengthening America’s economy and reducing its record-breaking debt.

Indian Immigrants: A Rational Blueprint for Immigration Reform

The report doesn’t just stop at highlighting numbers; it proposes an actionable path forward. Di Martino argues that reforming immigration policy to select highly skilled immigrants could reduce U.S. debt by $20 trillion over 30 years. He advocates for cutting total immigration by 10% while increasing high-skilled immigration, particularly through H-1B programs, by nearly 200%.

One of his most striking recommendations is to grant more green cards to Indian immigrants, who currently face decades-long backlogs due to outdated country quotas. By temporarily limiting new visa issuances from other countries, the U.S. could help clear this bottleneck and retain the highly educated Indian talent already contributing massively to its economy.

“Fiscal impact shouldn’t be the sole criterion for immigration policy,” Di Martino cautions. “But it’s a crucial and quantifiable measure of long-term national interest. A well-designed policy mix can strengthen the federal balance sheet, boost growth, and promote better assimilation.”

The National Debt Crisis: America’s Mounting Challenge

The release of this research comes at a time when the U.S. faces an unprecedented debt burden. As of this week, America’s gross national debt has surpassed $38 trillion, setting yet another record, according to the U.S. Treasury Department. The rate of increase — adding $1 trillion in less than three months — is the fastest since the pandemic era.

Experts like Kent Smetters from the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School warn that a ballooning debt load ultimately translates into higher inflation, lower wages, and weaker purchasing power for future generations. “People want to know their kids will be in good shape in the future — that they’ll be able to afford homes,” Smetters told the Associated Press. “But that additional inflation erodes purchasing power and opportunities.”

Ironically, Trump — who once vowed to eliminate the national debt — may find his best allies in Indian immigrants, the very group his rhetoric often sidelines. The same professionals he sought to restrict through visa limitations are those most capable of helping America recover financially.

Also Read : Nik: Turning Data, Creativity, and Strategy into Brand Magic