In the annals of South Africa’s legal history, few names resonate with as much respect and admiration as Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane. Born on August 19, 1965, in Durban, Kathree-Setiloane has carved an illustrious path through the country’s legal system, culminating in her recent appointment to the Supreme Court of Appeal in December 2023. Her journey is not just a testament to her legal acumen but also an inspiring narrative of resilience, dedication, and unwavering commitment to justice.
Early Life and Education of Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane: Laying the Foundation for Excellence
Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane’s early years in Durban set the stage for her future achievements. Demonstrating an early passion for justice and equality, she pursued higher education at the University of Natal. There, she earned a Bachelor of Arts in 1988 followed by a Bachelor of Laws in 1991.
Her academic prowess was evident as she balanced her studies with her role as a research assistant at the Centre for Socio-Legal Studies. This period was pivotal, shaping her understanding of socio-legal dynamics and fueling her commitment to constitutional rights.
Her academic journey took her across the Atlantic to the prestigious Georgetown University Law Center on a Fulbright Scholarship, where she completed her Master of Laws in 1993. This international exposure broadened her legal perspective, equipping her with the knowledge and skills that would later define her career.
Legal Practice: Championing Constitutional Rights and Gender Equality
Upon returning to South Africa in the prelude to the first post-apartheid general election, Kathree-Setiloane swiftly immersed herself in the nation’s transformative legal landscape. Her brief tenure as an elections administrator for the Independent Electoral Commission in the Northern Cape underscored her commitment to democratic principles.
Joining the public law department at the University of the Western Cape, Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane lectured in international human rights law and contributed significantly to the university’s Community Law Centre’s gender project. Her early involvement with Agenda, a prominent feminist journal, where she served on the editorial board and penned insightful columns on “Judges and Gender,” highlighted her dedication to gender equality within the judiciary.
As an advocate of the High Court in Johannesburg, Kathree-Setiloane specialized in constitutional litigation. Her tenure at the Legal Resources Centre was marked by pivotal cases, including her role in the landmark decision affirming the constitutional right for same-sex couples to marry. This ruling not only advanced LGBTQ+ rights in South Africa but also demonstrated her unwavering stance on equality and human rights.
Judicial Ascendancy: From Gauteng High Court to Supreme Court of Appeal
Kathree-Setiloane’s judicial career commenced in earnest in October 2006 when she transitioned from private practice to corporate advisory at Werksmans Advisory Services. Her multifaceted experience in both public and private sectors enriched her legal perspective, making her a formidable advocate and later, a respected judge.
Her permanent appointment to the Gauteng High Court in October 2010 by President Jacob Zuma marked the beginning of a 13-year tenure characterized by incisive judgments and a commitment to upholding the rule of law. Over 40 of her judgments were reported, many of which were upheld by higher courts, including the Constitutional Court.
Notable cases, such as the suspension of Robert McBride from the Independent Police Investigative Directorate and disputes involving the controversial Gupta family, showcased her ability to navigate complex legal and ethical landscapes with grace and authority.
Overcoming Challenges: The Road to the Constitutional Court
Despite her impressive credentials, Kathree-Setiloane’s path to the Constitutional Court was fraught with challenges. Twice shortlisted by the Judicial Service Commission for appointment to the highest court, Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane faced scrutiny during her interviews.
Critics questioned her demeanor and professional courtesy, citing instances from her acting tenure in the Constitutional Court. However, these challenges did not deter her. Instead, they fueled her determination to continue serving with integrity and professionalism.
In 2021, despite facing criticism during her interview process, Kathree-Setiloane was recommended as a suitable candidate by the Judicial Service Commission. Although she was not selected, the persistent efforts and unwavering commitment to her principles underscored her resilience and dedication to justice.
Supreme Court of Appeal: A Well-Deserved Appointment
Kathree-Setiloane’s perseverance paid off in October 2023 when she was recommended for appointment to the Supreme Court of Appeal. Recognized as the most senior woman judge at the Johannesburg High Court and having served multiple terms as an acting judge in the Supreme Court, her elevation was both a personal triumph and a significant milestone for gender representation in South Africa’s judiciary.
Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane’s appointment was a moment of celebration, symbolizing not just her individual achievements but also the broader progress towards a more inclusive and representative legal system. As a permanent judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal, Kathree-Setiloane is poised to influence South Africa’s legal landscape profoundly, ensuring that justice remains accessible and equitable for all.
Also Read:Quarraisha Abdool Karim: Pioneering Solutions for Global Health Challenges