One-Third of Americans Agree with Trump’s “Poisoning the Blood” Immigrant Claim

A newly released poll conducted by the Brookings Institution and the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) has revealed that a substantial portion of Americans share a controversial belief that echoes language rooted in dangerous historical rhetoric. The poll, which surveyed over 5,000 individual Americans between August 16 and September 4, found that 34% of Americans agree with former President Donald Trump’s claim that undocumented immigrants are “poisoning the blood” of the United States.

The phrase, which Trump used during a rally in New Hampshire in December 2023, has drawn significant backlash, especially given its historical connotations. In his speech, Trump stated, “They’ve let – I think the real number is 15, 16 million people into our country. When they do that, we’ve got a lot of work to do. They’re poisoning the blood of our country.”

The comment, which has been widely criticized by some Americans, reflects a broader narrative that Trump has used to rally support for his immigration policies. According to the poll, Republicans are overwhelmingly aligned with this sentiment, with 61% of GOP respondents agreeing with the statement. In contrast, only 30% of independents and 13% of Democrats expressed agreement.

Rising Rhetoric and Historical Echoes Between Americans

Critics have pointed out that Trump’s use of the phrase “poisoning the blood” bears a striking resemblance to language used by Adolf Hitler in his infamous manifesto, Mein Kampf. Hitler’s notion of “blood poisoning” was a key element of his racist ideology, making Trump’s echo of such rhetoric especially concerning.

“This is a truly alarming situation to see this kind of rhetoric, and this level of support from one of our two major political parties,” said Robert Jones, president and founder of PRRI, during the presentation of the poll’s findings. “That language is straight out of Mein Kampf. This idea of ‘poisoning the blood’ is Nazi rhetoric,” he added, noting that the increasing support for this type of language reflects deeper issues within the political and cultural fabric of the country.

Americans: The Political Divide

The poll’s results reflect a stark divide in how Americans view immigration and the role of undocumented immigrants in society. While Trump has repeatedly doubled down on his controversial remarks, emphasizing the need for stricter immigration policies, opposition to this rhetoric has come from a wide spectrum, including Democrats, immigrant rights groups, and the Biden campaign.

At the time of Trump’s December rally, his comments drew immediate condemnation from President Joe Biden’s campaign. “We are not only witnessing dangerous words from Donald Trump but the normalization of dehumanizing language that divides our nation,” a Biden campaign spokesperson said in response.

Trump’s Supporters and the Future of Democracy

Beyond immigration, the poll uncovered other worrisome trends about Trump’s supporters. Nearly one in four of Trump’s backers, 23%, stated that if he were to lose the upcoming presidential election, he should declare the results invalid and take whatever steps are necessary to assume office. This sentiment is a reflection of the increasingly radical positions held by certain segments of the electorate.

The poll’s revelations have heightened concerns over the future of American democracy, with many warning that the use of such inflammatory language could incite further division and unrest.

The Broader Implications

The poll’s findings indicate that the rhetoric of fear and division continues to resonate deeply within certain parts of the American electorate. As immigration remains a hot-button issue leading into the 2024 election, the use of phrases like “poisoning the blood” signals the potential for escalating polarization.

Experts warn that this kind of language could have lasting impacts on the country’s social fabric. “We’ve seen throughout history that when dehumanizing language is used to describe any group, it opens the door to further discrimination, violence, and policy decisions rooted in fear rather than facts,” said a political analyst who reviewed the poll’s results.